I actually prefer the theatrical cut of Fellowship (which is still overwhelmingly the best individual film of the trilogy IMO). It flows much better and the added scenes don't really change anything narratively.
TTT is a no-brainer though, the extended edition fixes a whole bunch of problems with the short version. RotK I can take either way - it contains scenes which actively worsen the theatrical version and PJ was a fool for adding them... but some other additions do fix a couple of problems.
I Just Watched (Films)
- Animalmother
- Local
- Posts: 3493
- Joined: Fri Aug 10, 2018 3:44 pm
Re: I Just Watched (Films)
Just found this. He goes into a lot of detail so it gets into a bit of military speak in places.
TLDW..
TLDW..
Spoiler
Re: I Just Watched (Films)
Enjoyed that!
"Unlike the film, we will maintain fire discipline."data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/60d19/60d19e746b4049a23efed700af656e1d8198861a" alt="Laughing :lol:"
"Unlike the film, we will maintain fire discipline."
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/60d19/60d19e746b4049a23efed700af656e1d8198861a" alt="Laughing :lol:"
- Animalmother
- Local
- Posts: 3493
- Joined: Fri Aug 10, 2018 3:44 pm
Re: I Just Watched (Films)
Furiosa: A Mad Max Saga
I loved Fury Road, it was balls out insane with some amazing stunts and action. This is also nuts with some great action but it just felt a bit flat. I did very much enjoy but it feels a bit all over the place. There was a very obvious change from practical stunts to mostly CGI and it just lacks the excitement of FR. It interestingly adds characters from the recent game (Scrotus and Chum Bucket) and things like the maggot farm.
Very enjoyable but pales in comparison to Fury Road.
I loved Fury Road, it was balls out insane with some amazing stunts and action. This is also nuts with some great action but it just felt a bit flat. I did very much enjoy but it feels a bit all over the place. There was a very obvious change from practical stunts to mostly CGI and it just lacks the excitement of FR. It interestingly adds characters from the recent game (Scrotus and Chum Bucket) and things like the maggot farm.
Very enjoyable but pales in comparison to Fury Road.
- Stormbringer
- Rad Dad
- Posts: 1952
- Joined: Fri Aug 10, 2018 9:57 am
- Location: Hyperborea
Re: I Just Watched (Films)
Quite agree. It lacks the tight cohesiveness of the first and feels like a strange mashup of ideas that don't really adhere well.
"Animalmother" wrote:Violence is often the best solution.
- Hatredsheart
- Posts: 1442
- Joined: Fri Aug 10, 2018 7:43 am
- Location: Circling The Drain
Re: I Just Watched (Films)
Companion
Really enjoyed it. Saw a spoiler-free article that advised going into it without reviews, glad I did.
Don't watch the trailer!
Really enjoyed it. Saw a spoiler-free article that advised going into it without reviews, glad I did.
Don't watch the trailer!
Formerly Dr@gon-UK, but still the Forum Fossil
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/e545e/e545e02dc2da1f6b9fdcfe4f345bdbc0c535af40" alt="Image"
π―ππ'π ππππ πΏππ π½πππππ
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/e545e/e545e02dc2da1f6b9fdcfe4f345bdbc0c535af40" alt="Image"
π―ππ'π ππππ πΏππ π½πππππ
Re: I Just Watched (Films)
Literally this second finished watching it. Great film. Actually funny bits too. Great acting all round.
I saw a youtube vide from Mark Komode saying don't watch any trailers.
I thought I'd sussed it out but there weren't really any plot twists as such, but it was so different from what I'd decided it would be about.
I saw a youtube vide from Mark Komode saying don't watch any trailers.
I thought I'd sussed it out but there weren't really any plot twists as such, but it was so different from what I'd decided it would be about.
-- To be completed at some point --
Re: I Just Watched (Films)
Uh lets see....
Witness For The Prosecution
Fantastic! 9/10
Heart Eyes
Shite but could be worse. 3/10
Nightbitch
Could have been much better if it went less preachy. 5/10
Imaginary
Killer teddybear. Shite. Surprisingly. 2/10
Storm In A Teacup
Lovely! Lots of cute dogs, a cute Vivien Leigh and the rest was pretty good too. 8/10
Witness For The Prosecution
Fantastic! 9/10
Heart Eyes
Shite but could be worse. 3/10
Nightbitch
Could have been much better if it went less preachy. 5/10
Imaginary
Killer teddybear. Shite. Surprisingly. 2/10
Storm In A Teacup
Lovely! Lots of cute dogs, a cute Vivien Leigh and the rest was pretty good too. 8/10
A man who could tell more truth and eat fewer pies.